Discussion: episode where derek took John to see his father as child

"I loved that scene. It was so powerful it moved me to tears. Poor John is always trying to find out things about his father, like what was he like or how did he look. I think that Derek gave him the best birthday present ever!!!! And also the best compliment by telling John that every time he looks at him, he sees Kyle, The expression on John's face was priceless!!!!!!"

"Agreeing with everything that's been said. This is definitely one of the show's most memorable scenes. John's expression - what a way to drive home the sadness and longing he feels for a father he's never known and the knowledge that when he does get to befriend him in the future, can never know of their true relationship. I must have watched this scene 20 times and never tire of it."